Return Analytics and Reporting

Returns Analytics Guide

Understanding your return data helps reduce costs, improve products, and optimize the customer experience. Data-driven return management can reduce return rates by 15-20%.

Why Return Analytics Matter

---

Key Return Metrics

Return Rate

Return Rate = (Returns / Orders) × 100

Industry Benchmarks:

Track by:

• Product category
• Individual SKU
• Customer segment
• Time period (seasonal trends)
• Marketing channel

Return Cost

Total Return Cost = Shipping + Processing + Lost Revenue

Full Cost Calculation:

Example: $50 Product Return

Return shipping:      $8.00
Inspection labor:     $5.00
Restock time:         $3.00
Packaging:            $1.50
Resale discount:      $10.00 (20%)
Holding cost:         $2.00
─────────────────────────────
Total cost:           $29.50 (59% of sale price)

Return Reason Analysis

Track why items are returned:

---

Accessing Return Reports

Navigate to Reports → Returns

Available Reports

1. Return Overview Dashboard

   • Total returns this period
   • Return rate trend
   • Top return reasons
   • Cost summary

2. Product Return Analysis

   • Returns by SKU
   • Return rate ranking
   • Reason breakdown by product
   • Cost per product category

3. Return Reason Deep Dive

   • Reason trends over time
   • Reason by product category
   • Reason by customer segment
   • Photo analysis (for defects)

4. Financial Impact Report

   • Total return shipping spend
   • Cost per return by carrier
   • Refund amounts
   • Net revenue impact

5. Customer Return Behavior

   • Return frequency by customer
   • Serial returner identification
   • Lifetime value vs return rate
   • Segment analysis

6. Operational Metrics

   • Time to process returns
   • Carrier transit times
   • Refund processing time
   • Automation success rate

---

Reducing Return Rates

Analyze Product Data

High-Return Products:

1. Pull report of SKUs with >30% return rate
2. Analyze return reasons
3. Compare to similar products
4. Identify patterns

Questions to Ask:

• Are sizes running small/large?
• Do photos accurately represent product?
• Is quality consistent?
• Are care instructions clear?

Solutions by Problem

Improve Product Listings

Based on return data:

• Add size comparison charts
• Include fit recommendations ("runs small, size up")
• Show product in context
• Add customer review insights
• Include video demonstrations
• Display return rate (social proof for low-return items)

---

Financial Analysis

Calculate True Return Cost Per SKU

For each product:
1. Average return rate
2. Average return shipping cost
3. Average processing cost
4. Average resale discount
5. Customer acquisition cost portion

True Cost = Sum of above × return rate

Example Analysis:

Build Returns Into Pricing

For high-return categories (apparel):

Target Margin + (Return Rate × Return Cost) = Required Markup
25% + (30% × 50% of price) = 40% markup needed

Carrier Cost Optimization

Analyze return shipping costs by carrier:

Recommendation: Use USPS for cost, UPS for reliability/speed

---

Custom Report Builder

Create custom reports:

1. Select Date Range

   • Last 7/30/90 days
   • Custom range
   • Compare to previous period

2. Choose Metrics

   • Return count
   • Return rate
   • Return cost
   • Refund amount
   • Processing time

3. Add Filters

   • Product category
   • Customer segment
   • Return reason
   • Carrier
   • Order value range

4. Group By

   • Day/Week/Month
   • Product
   • Category
   • Reason
   • Carrier

5. Export

   • CSV for Excel analysis
   • PDF for reporting
   • API for dashboards

---

Actionable Insights Playbook

Weekly Review

• Check return rate trend
• Review top 5 return reasons
• Identify any spikes or anomalies

Monthly Analysis

• Product return rate ranking
• Cost per return trend
• Carrier performance comparison
• Customer segment analysis

Quarterly Deep Dive

• Full financial impact analysis
• Product listing improvements
• Supplier quality review
• Policy effectiveness assessment

Annual Planning

• Set return rate targets by category
• Budget for return costs
• Plan product improvements
• Evaluate return policy changes

---

Benchmarking Your Performance

Good Performance Indicators

• Return rate at or below industry average
• Cost per return declining over time
• "Changed mind" as top reason (vs quality issues)
• Processing time under 48 hours
• High automation rate (>80%)

Warning Signs

• Return rate increasing month over month
• Single product driving most returns
• "Defective" or "Not as described" trending up
• Long processing times
• High customer complaints about returns

---

Related Articles

• Creating Return Labels: Complete Guide
• Return Label Costs: Understanding Pricing
• Automating Your Return Process