Seller Background
Seller: HomeEssentials Direct (name changed)
Marketplace: Amazon (100% FBM)
Monthly Orders: 4,200
Product Category: Home & Kitchen
Previous Avg Ship Cost: $7.85
Fulfillment: In-house warehouse (Phoenix, AZ)
The FBM Challenge
FBM sellers compete directly with FBA Prime offerings. This creates pressure to:
- Match Prime delivery speeds
- Keep shipping costs competitive
- Maintain excellent metrics
- Handle customer expectations
Initial Metrics
| Metric | Value | Target |
|---|
| Monthly shipping spend | $32,970 | Reduce 25%+ |
| Late shipment rate | 2.8% | Under 4% |
| Valid tracking rate | 96.2% | Above 95% |
| On-time delivery | 89% | Above 90% |
| Avg delivery time | 5.2 days | Under 5 days |
Problem Analysis
Cost Breakdown by Product Type
| Product Type | % Orders | Weight | Ship Cost |
|---|
| Small kitchen | 45% | 0.5-1 lb | $5.20 |
| Medium home | 35% | 1-3 lbs | $8.45 |
| Large decor | 20% | 3-8 lbs | $14.80 |
Shipping Pattern Analysis
| Issue | Impact |
|---|
| UPS-only strategy | Missing USPS savings for light items |
| Manual carrier selection | Inconsistent decisions |
| No Seller Fulfilled Prime | Missing Prime visibility |
| Afternoon cutoff | Orders wait until next day |
Solution Strategy
Phase 1: Multi-Carrier Implementation
Added USPS Ground Advantage for sub-2 lb packages
| Weight | UPS Ground | USPS Ground Advantage | Savings |
|---|
| 8 oz | $8.20 | $4.50 | 45% |
| 1 lb | $9.45 | $5.85 | 38% |
| 1.5 lbs | $10.80 | $7.25 | 33% |
| 2 lbs | $11.95 | $8.45 | 29% |
Phase 2: Carrier Selection Rules
Automated rules based on package characteristics:
Small Kitchen Items (under 1 lb):
→ USPS Ground Advantage (always)Medium Home Items (1-3 lbs):
→ USPS if Zone 1-5
→ UPS if Zone 6-8 (faster)
Large Decor (3+ lbs):
→ UPS Ground (better handling)
→ FedEx Ground if fragile
All Orders:
→ Add signature if value > $100
→ Use fastest carrier if SFP-eligible
Phase 3: Process Optimization
Extended shipping cutoff:
- Before: 2:00 PM cutoff
- After: 5:00 PM cutoff (carrier pickup at 6 PM)
Impact:
- 30% more orders ship same day
- Better on-time delivery rate
- Improved customer satisfaction
Phase 4: Seller Fulfilled Prime Preparation
Metrics improvement for SFP eligibility:
| Requirement | Before | After | Target |
|---|
| On-time delivery | 89% | 96% | 93.5%+ |
| Valid tracking | 96.2% | 99.4% | 99%+ |
| Late shipment | 2.8% | 0.9% | Under 4% |
| Cancellation rate | 1.2% | 0.6% | Under 2.5% |
Results After 4 Months
Cost Reduction
| Metric | Before | After | Change |
|---|
| Avg cost/order | $7.85 | $4.87 | -38% |
| Monthly spend | $32,970 | $20,454 | -38% |
| Annual savings | - | - | $150,192 |
Carrier Distribution
| Carrier | % of Orders | Avg Cost | Use Case |
|---|
| USPS Ground | 55% | $3.85 | Light items |
| UPS Ground | 35% | $6.20 | Heavy/fragile |
| FedEx Ground | 8% | $5.85 | Fragile items |
| USPS Priority | 2% | $8.40 | Rush orders |
| Metric | Before | After | Change |
|---|
| Late shipment rate | 2.8% | 0.9% | -68% |
| On-time delivery | 89% | 96% | +7 pp |
| Valid tracking | 96.2% | 99.4% | +3.2 pp |
| Avg delivery time | 5.2 days | 3.8 days | -1.4 days |
Amazon Metrics Impact
Account Health
| Metric | Before | After | Status |
|---|
| Order defect rate | 0.8% | 0.4% | Excellent |
| Cancellation rate | 1.2% | 0.6% | Excellent |
| Late shipment rate | 2.8% | 0.9% | Excellent |
Customer Feedback
| Metric | Before | After |
|---|
| Shipping feedback | 4.2/5 | 4.7/5 |
| "Arrived on time" | 85% | 94% |
| Negative shipping reviews | 12/mo | 3/mo |
Seller Fulfilled Prime Achievement
After 3 months of improved metrics, seller qualified for SFP:
SFP Impact
| Metric | Before SFP | With SFP | Change |
|---|
| Daily orders | 140 | 185 | +32% |
| Conversion rate | 8.2% | 11.5% | +40% |
| Average order value | $42 | $45 | +7% |
Revenue Impact
- Monthly order increase: 1,350 orders
- Additional monthly revenue: $60,750
- Annual revenue increase: $729,000
Implementation Costs
| Investment | Amount |
|---|
| Atoship subscription | $99/month |
| Integration setup | $500 (one-time) |
| Process redesign | 20 hours staff time |
| Training | 4 hours |
| Total First Year | $1,688 |
ROI Calculation
| Benefit | Annual Value |
|---|
| Shipping savings | $150,192 |
| Revenue from SFP | $729,000 |
| Labor savings | $8,400 |
| Total Benefit | $887,592 |
Key Learnings
What Worked
USPS for light items: 55% of orders shifted to USPS, saving 38%
Automated selection: Consistent optimal decisions
Extended cutoff: More same-day shipping
Metrics focus: Led to SFP qualificationChallenges Overcome
| Challenge | Solution |
|---|
| USPS tracking less detailed | Set customer expectations |
| Carrier pickup coordination | Scheduled pickups from all carriers |
| Staff training | 2-week transition period |
| Amazon integration | Used Atoship's Buy Shipping API |
Recommendations for FBM Sellers
Priority Actions
Analyze order weight distribution
Add USPS for lightweight items
Implement automated carrier selection
Extend shipping cutoff timeFor SFP Aspirants
Focus on tracking and on-time metrics
Build 3-month performance history
Consider regional fulfillment
Prepare for increased volumeStart Optimizing Your FBM Shipping
Create your Atoship account for Amazon FBM integration and multi-carrier rate shopping.
Ready to save on shipping?
Get started with Atoship for free and access discounted USPS, UPS, and FedEx rates. No monthly fees, no contracts.
Create Free Account
