Multi-Carrier Shipping Strategy: Diversify Your Delivery Options

Relying on a single shipping carrier limits your options and exposes your business to risk. A multi-carrier strategy provides flexibility, better rates, and improved service levels. Here's how to implement one effectively.

Why Multi-Carrier Matters

Risk Mitigation

• Protection against carrier disruptions
• Coverage during peak season capacity issues
• Backup options for service failures
• Geographic coverage gaps filled

Cost Optimization

• Rate shopping for best prices
• Leverage competitive rates
• Match service level to need
• Avoid carrier-specific surcharges

Service Improvement

• Faster delivery options
• Better geographic coverage
• Specialized services access
• Customer choice flexibility

Major Carriers Overview

USPS

Best for:

• Lightweight packages (under 1 lb)
• Residential deliveries
• Rural areas
• First Class and Priority Mail

Advantages:

• Lowest rates for light packages
• Universal residential access
• No residential surcharges
• Saturday delivery included

UPS

Best for:

• Heavy packages (over 10 lbs)
• Business-to-business shipping
• Ground shipping reliability
• Time-definite services

Advantages:

• Extensive ground network
• Strong B2B presence
• Pickup services
• Reliable tracking

FedEx

Best for:

• Express shipping needs
• Time-sensitive deliveries
• International shipping
• High-value items

Advantages:

• Fast transit times
• Strong international network
• Advanced tracking
• Money-back guarantee

Regional Carriers

Consider for:

• Specific geographic areas
• Cost savings on local delivery
• Faster regional transit
• Specialized services

Examples:

• OnTrac (Western US)
• LSO (Southwest US)
• Spee-Dee (Midwest)
• Eastern Connection (Northeast)

Implementing Multi-Carrier Strategy

Step 1: Analyze Your Shipping Profile

• Package weight distribution
• Delivery zone patterns
• Service level requirements
• Current cost breakdown

Step 2: Evaluate Carrier Options

• Request quotes from multiple carriers
• Compare service levels
• Assess coverage areas
• Review technology integration

Step 3: Set Up Accounts

• Negotiate rates based on volume
• Establish pickup schedules
• Configure technology connections
• Test shipping workflows

Step 4: Create Shipping Rules

• Weight-based carrier selection
• Zone-based routing
• Service level matching
• Cost threshold triggers

Rate Shopping Technology

Shipping Software Features

• Real-time rate comparison
• Automated carrier selection
• Rule-based routing
• Cost optimization algorithms

Integration Requirements

• API connections to carriers
• Shopping cart integration
• Order management sync
• Label printing automation

Best Practices

Carrier Selection Rules

By Package Characteristics:

By Delivery Speed:

Customer Communication

• Display delivery estimates accurately
• Offer carrier choice at checkout
• Provide tracking for all shipments
• Set realistic expectations

Managing Multiple Carriers

Operational Considerations

• Standardized pickup schedules
• Unified tracking systems
• Consolidated reporting
• Streamlined returns process

Monitoring Performance

• Track delivery times by carrier
• Monitor damage rates
• Measure customer satisfaction
• Compare cost per package

Cost Negotiation Tips

Volume Leverage

• Aggregate volume across carriers
• Use competitive quotes as leverage
• Negotiate annually
• Consider guaranteed volume commitments

Hidden Savings

• Residential surcharge comparisons
• Fuel surcharge differences
• Dimensional weight policies
• Accessorial fee structures

Technology Solutions

Shipping Platforms

• Multi-carrier rate shopping
• Automated label generation
• Unified tracking
• Analytics and reporting

Key Features to Look For

• Real-time rate accuracy
• Easy carrier addition
• Flexible routing rules
• Integration capabilities

Conclusion

A multi-carrier shipping strategy is essential for e-commerce success. By leveraging the strengths of different carriers, you can optimize costs, improve delivery times, and provide better customer experiences.

---

AtoShip connects you to all major carriers in one platform, making multi-carrier shipping strategy implementation simple and effective.